Date | Location | Won | Won From | Notes |
| 6/16/03 |
Dallas Pike, WV |
Nikita Allanov |
Daron Smythe |
A lottery was held to determine Allanov and Smythe as the top 2 contenders to the title
|
| 3/21/04 |
Moundsville, WV |
Daron Smythe |
Nikita Allanov |
n/a |
| 5/20/05 |
Brilliant, OH |
Devin Devine |
Daron Smythe |
n/a |
| 8/28/05 |
Martins Ferry, OH |
Justin Idol |
Devin Devine |
Idol forfeited the title due to injury on 12/11/05 |
| 2/18/06 |
Martins Ferry, OH |
Nikita Allanov |
Justin Idol |
This match was for the vacated title |
| 7/2/06 |
Martins Ferry, OH |
Sam Slej |
Nikita Allanov |
n/a |
| 9/3/06 |
Martins Ferry, OH |
Nikita Allanov |
Sam Slej |
n/a |
| 4/20/07 |
Brilliant, OH |
Chris Kole |
Nikita Allanov |
n/a |
| 7/8/07 |
Moundsville, WV |
Justin Idol |
Chris Kole, Nikita Allanov, and Jason Gory |
Fatal 4 Way Elimination Match |
| 6/15/08 |
Bridgeport, OH |
Jason Gory |
Justin Idol |
n/a |
| 5/8/11 |
Moundsville, WV |
Michael Facade |
Jason Gory |
n/a |
| 9/11/11 |
Moundsville, WV |
Dash Bennett |
Jason Gory, Chest Flexor, and Dan Sandwich |
Fatal 4 Way for the vacated title |
| 11/18/11 |
Brilliant, OH |
Dan Sandwich |
Dash Bennett |
n/a |