Date | Location | Won | Won From | Notes |
| 6/16/03 | Dallas Pike, WV | Harold Potter | Battle Royal | Potter won a battle royal, last eliminating Stacy Hunter. He was awarded the title after the match. |
| 8/29/03 | Dallas Pike, WV | Mark Steele | Harold Potter | This was a tag team match also involving Dash Bennett and Kid Cupid. The title is allowed to change hands in the match due to 24/7 rules. |
| 8/29/03 | Dallas Pike, WV | Tony Summers | Mark Steele | n/a |
| 8/29/03 | Dallas Pike, WV | Mark Steele | Tony Summers | n/a |
| 8/29/03 | Dallas Pike, WV | Krystal Frost | Battle Royal | This was an impromptu battle royal. The title was on the line due to Steele being a participant. |
| 10/18/03 | Dallas Pike, WV | Kid Cupid | Krystal Frost | n/a |
| 3/21/04 | Moundsville, WV | The Shocker | Kid Cupid | n/a |
| 10/16/04 | Wheeling, WV | Ryan Spade | The Shocker | n/a |
| 4/10/05 | Martins Ferry, OH | Kid Cupid | Ryan Spade | n/a |
| 12/11/05 | Martins Ferry, OH | Eisen Drache | Kid Cupid | Championship retired after this match |