Date | Location | Won | Won From | Notes |
| 5/7/06 |
Martins Ferry, OH |
Jason Cage |
Jason Gory, Shiima Xion, Dan Sandwich |
This was a Fatal 4-Way "Towers Of Doom" Match to crown the first Champion; Cage forfeits title on 11/16/06 due to injury |
| 11/19/06 |
Martins Ferry, OH |
Jason Gory |
Sabotage, Justin Idol, Shiima Xion |
This was a Fatal 4-Way "Tower Of Terror" Match for the vacated title |
| 10/14/07 |
Wheeling, WV |
Jimmy DeMarco |
Jason Gory, Dan Sandwich, Justin Idol |
This was a Fatal 4-Way "2 Towers Of Terror" Match; DeMarco captured the Diamond Division title |
| 11/9/08 |
Bridgeport, OH |
Dan Sandwich |
Bobby Digital, DJ Tom Sharp |
This was a Triple Threat Match; the Atheletic Commision stripped DeMarco of the Diamond Division title |
| 6/5/09 |
Bridgeport, OH |
Michael Facade |
Dan Sandwich, Justin Idol, and Chris LeRusso |
n/a |
| 5/23/10 |
Brilliant, OH |
Zero |
Michael Facade, Jason Cage, and Chest Flexor |
Ladder Match |
| 3/13/10 |
Moundsville, WV |
Jay Flash |
Alex Arcadian, and Nick Mirra |
Zero had to surrender title due to injury |